SI01 - Sanibel Island Homes with Yes Pets

Welcome to Sanibel Island, a breathtaking gem nestled in Lee County, Florida, where sun-kissed shores meet a vibrant community spirit. Renowned for its pristine beaches and lush natural surroundings, Sanibel Island offers a unique blend of relaxation and adventure, making it an ideal destination for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a slice of paradise.

Sanibel Island is famous for its commitment to preserving its natural beauty. With over half of the island designated as wildlife refuge, residents and visitors alike can enjoy the abundant wildlife and stunning scenery. From shelling on the world-renowned beaches to kayaking through mangroves, there’s no shortage of outdoor activities to indulge in. The island is also home to an array of charming shops, delectable dining options, and a rich cultural scene that includes art galleries and local festivals.

For pet lovers, Sanibel Island is a welcoming haven. Many homes in this idyllic region embrace a pet-friendly policy, allowing you to bring your furry friends along to enjoy the coastal lifestyle. Imagine morning walks along sandy paths with your dog or relaxing on your porch while your pets frolic in your spacious backyard. Homes here are designed with both comfort and convenience in mind, often featuring ample outdoor space perfect for your pets to roam freely.

Whether you’re looking for a cozy cottage, a luxurious beachfront property, or a family home, Sanibel Island offers diverse real estate options tailored to meet your needs. Come discover why so many choose to call this enchanting island home, where every day feels like a vacation, and your pets are welcomed with open arms!

Newest SI01 - Sanibel Island Homes with Yes Pets

$1,749,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 2026045409 MLS

Located in one of Sanibel’s most charming neighborhoods, 1057 Seahawk Lane is built for the best of island living. It is elevated, remodeled, and set on nearly three-quarters of an acre of private grounds, just a short stroll to the beach. The Beach Road beach access is a short walk from the front door, and a public beach parking lot (by permit) is even closer. The large lot backs up to the Sanibel River, where mature landscaping wraps the home in genuine visual privacy and creates a natural buffer from the homes beyond. Privacy like this is a rare find on the island. The Seahawk HOA is a quiet enclave of only seven homes, with its own tennis court that is also lined for pickleball. The home is elevated on pilings and protected by a metal roof (2021), impact windows (2019), and shutter-protected sliders. Inside, the renovation reconfigured the kitchen and primary bath including a California Closet system, wide door and window trim, crown molding and durable luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout. The open living and kitchen area gathers around a custom wood-topped island. Sliders open to a large, screened porch overlooking the pool, the yard, and lush trees and foliage. The free-form pool and spa were added in 2021, with a wide sun shelf for lounging or wading and pool equipment updated and installed between 2023-2026. Below the home, new pavers create an oversized driveway and a shaded ground-level space for relaxing or a game of table tennis. The lower-level storage has a new epoxy floor (2025) for durability and easy cleanup. The east-end location keeps the Causeway close for off-island trips, with many of Sanibel’s favorite restaurants nearby. Close to the beach, private by nature, and the hard work already done. Come see 1057 Seahawk Lane.

1057 Seahawk LN, Sanibel

$2,250,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 2026045834 MLS

Discover an extraordinary opportunity to embrace the quintessential Sanibel Island lifestyle in this stately near beach Gulf-access home overlooking the breathtaking waters of Dinkins Bayou. Offering stunning water views and an exceptional location on Sanibel’s peaceful and sparsely populated west end, this island retreat perfectly blends coastal elegance with the natural beauty that makes Sanibel so special. With over an acre of land, the home offers great privacy and the ability to make future improvements. Water heater, roof, electrical, plumbing and AC improvements made from 2022- 2026. Storm protection at all doors and windows and a private elevator add great convenience and peace of mind. Approximately a half mile away, the pristine shores of Blind Pass Beach await, easily reached along the scenic island bike path with convenient access directly from the property. Spend your days enjoying the island's world-renowned shelling, spectacular sunsets, boating adventures, and the tranquility of this remarkable coastal setting. With picturesque bayou views, Gulf access, and close proximity to one of Sanibel's most treasured beaches, this exceptional property presents a rare opportunity to experience the very best of island living.

6018 White Heron LN, Sanibel

$799,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026043293 MLS

Your Vision. Your Waterfront. Your Sanibel. Welcome to 1083 South Yachtsman Drive, Sanibel Island! This home offers a rare opportunity to create your own waterfront retreat on Sanibel's sought-after East End. Located in the desirable Sanibel Estates neighborhood, this 0.35-acre canal-front property offers an exceptional combination of location, boating access, and possibilities. Just a short walk from the marina and iconic Grandma Dot's restaurant, you're also a short bike ride from Lighthouse Beach, community beach access, and the shops and restaurants along Periwinkle Way. Situated on a navigable canal, the property features a composite-decked dock, perfect for launching kayaks and canoes, with the potential to add a boat lift, subject to applicable regulations and approvals. The existing ground-level home offers three bedrooms plus a den, an open living, dining, and kitchen layout, and an in-ground pool surrounded by a spacious screened lanai. Remediated following Hurricane Ian but not yet rebuilt, the property presents a unique opportunity to renovate and customize the existing residence or explore the potential for new construction. With limited opportunities to create a custom waterfront home in this established East End neighborhood, 1083 South Yachtsman Drive offers the chance to bring your vision to life in one of Sanibel's most desirable locations. All renovations, new construction, and boating improvements are subject to applicable building codes, permitting requirements, and governmental approvals. Opportunities like this are increasingly rare on Sanibel’s East End, bring your vision and discover the potential of this exceptional waterfront property.

1083 S Yachtsman DR, Sanibel

$1,095,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 2026044185 MLS

Exceptional home on the quaint West End of Sanibel Island! This lovely property has three bedrooms and two 1/2 bathrooms. It is located within the gated community of Heron's Landing and is situated on a half-acre lot. Excellent floor plan with soaring ceilings, a great room with gorgeous wood flooring, kitchen with center island and dinette area, efficient laundry hub room, large pantry, spacious master suite with large bathroom boasting double sinks, shower and soaking tub, two spacious bedrooms that share a large guest bathroom. The screened deck offers electric storm shutters and scenic views of the tropical, natural landscape overlooking a small bayou which creates a private, secluded and verdant atmosphere. The two car garage has enough room to store 4 cars. Additional storage on the lower level area is perfect for creating the ultimate workshop with plenty of space for kayaks, bikes, fishing gear or a golf cart. Herons Landing offers a large, resort style community pool and spa complete with new deck furniture and nicely appointed bathrooms, a tennis court, kayak launch and a private beach access path leading to the sandy shores of Sanibel Island. A must see in every way!

5422 Osprey CT, Sanibel

$1,395,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026045224 MLS

Extensively Reimagined. Exceptionally Finished. A New-Home Experience on Sanibel. This is not simply an updated home. 1990 My Tern Court has undergone an extensive, top-to-bottom transformation designed to deliver the look, feel, comfort, and efficiency of a newly finished luxury residence within the existing home. At the heart of the transformation are a fully renovated kitchen and beautifully rebuilt bathrooms. The gourmet kitchen features Bertch cabinetry, quartz countertops and backsplash, Bosch induction range, dishwasher and refrigerator, under-cabinet lighting, designer range hood and Kohler fixtures. Both bathrooms showcase marble tile floors and showers, double vanities, Kohler fixtures and curbless showers, while the primary bath adds a freestanding soaking tub. The renovation extends throughout the interior with engineered hardwood floors, Level 5 smooth wall and ceiling finishes, new ceiling fans, bedroom closet organizers, Bertch built-ins with quartz surfaces, and a completely upgraded laundry room featuring an LG washer and dryer, LG Steam Closet, Bertch cabinetry, stainless-steel sink and tile flooring. Just as important is what buyers don't immediately see. Major home systems and exterior components were extensively upgraded in 2023 and 2024, including a metal roof, PEX plumbing, PGT windows and doors, Hardie siding, new electrical breaker panel and breakers, heat exchanger, programmable thermostat, backflow valve, Stiebel Eltron tankless water heater, Rain Bird four-zone irrigation, and an Aquasana four-filter whole-house water treatment system with UV light. The lower-level ceilings were also insulated and finished. The result is a 4-bedroom residence, with one bedroom currently used as an office, that combines sophisticated finishes with an extraordinary concentration of recent improvements. With its soaring vaulted ceilings, expansive screened lanai, oversized 3+ car garage, gated Herons Landing setting, resort-style community amenities, private deeded access to Bowman’s Beach and community kayak/paddleboard dock, this property offers more than beautiful surroundings. It offers the opportunity to enjoy the Sanibel lifestyle without taking on the time, expense and uncertainty of a major renovation. Nearly every place you look, something has been renewed, redesigned or upgraded. For the luxury buyer searching for a move-in-ready Sanibel home where the work has already been done, this is a rare opportunity.

1990 My Tern CT, Sanibel

$1,775,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026046372 MLS

Exceptional Bayfront Living on Sunset Bay & 150+ Feet of Waterfront Discover the beauty of bayfront living in this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 3-bath beach home, ideally situated along the coveted shores of Sunset Bay on Sanibel Island. Boasting more than 150 feet of waterfront, this exceptional property captures sweeping bay views and breathtaking sunsets from nearly every room. Designed for both relaxed island living and effortless entertaining, the home features an inviting electric fireplace, an expansive outdoor deck, a 2-car garage, and a private dock with boat lift. Step outside and enjoy direct water access, peaceful surroundings, and the freedom to embrace the boating lifestyle right from your backyard.

Sanibel

$897,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026046228 MLS

Private Sanibel Island Retreat – Private Pool, Community Tennis Court & Close proximity to the Beach Discover the best of Sanibel Island living in this exceptional private retreat, where tropical beauty, outdoor recreation, and island convenience come together. This beautifully situated raised 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers a versatile loft, ideal for a home office, additional guest space, or flexible bonus area. Thoughtfully positioned for privacy, the property backs directly to a peaceful preserve/park, creating a beautiful natural backdrop with no homes immediately behind you. Enjoy your own tropical oasis featuring your own saltwater pool, adjacent the tennis/pickleball court plus private community pool if you are feeling more social. Location is everything, and this home delivers. Situated directly alongside Sanibel's renowned bike trail, some can easily walk or bike to the beach while enjoying everything the island has to offer. Quick access to Periwinkle Way puts Sanibel's popular restaurants, boutique shopping, art galleries, and island attractions just moments away. Sanibel Island is celebrated for its breathtaking Gulf beaches, world-famous shelling, abundant wildlife, boating, fishing, and miles of scenic biking trails. Its relaxed coastal atmosphere and remarkable natural beauty make it one of Florida's most treasured island destinations. Whether enjoying a refreshing swim, playing tennis in your own backyard, biking to the beach, or simply relaxing while overlooking the peaceful preserve, this home offers an exceptional opportunity to embrace the Sanibel lifestyle. Property Highlights: • 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms • Versatile loft with potential for office or additional guest space • Raised home construction • Private swimming pool • Private tennis court • Private preserve/park backdrop • No homes immediately behind the property • Direct access alongside Sanibel's bike trail • Walk-or-bike access to the beach • Convenient access to Periwinkle Way, restaurants, shopping, and galleries Private when you want it. Convenient when you need it. The Sanibel lifestyle you've been dreaming of awaits.

750 Marthas LN, Sanibel

$2,999,000

6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 2026046138 MLS

**EXCEPTIONAL REDEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITY ON SANIBEL’S EAST END!** Situated on over an acre of lush tropical grounds just a short stroll from the beach, The Palms of Sanibel presents a rare opportunity for investors, developers, or buyers seeking a distinctive island retreat. With an allocated residential density of 2.2 dwelling units per acre and a minimum lot size of 10,000 square feet under F-Mid Island Ridge zoning, the property offers the potential for subdivision into three residential homesites or a thoughtfully designed cluster development, subject to applicable approvals. Whether creating three individual island residences, a private family compound, or reimagining the existing hospitality use, the possibilities make this an especially compelling offering. For those seeking an income-producing investment, The Palms of Sanibel offers an entirely different opportunity. This charming boutique inn is perfectly positioned to become a sought-after Airbnb-style vacation rental destination, awaiting its next owner's personal vision, creativity, and finishing touches. Two coastal-style buildings accommodate four individual rental cottages, each featuring their own kitchen, living area, bedroom accommodations, and private bath. Select cottages also feature screened porches overlooking the tropical surroundings. Following Hurricane Ian, the buildings were stripped to the studs and extensively renovated with all-new mechanical systems, electrical, plumbing, appliances, and furnishings. Modern conveniences include fiber-optic internet and property-wide Wi-Fi coverage, providing the connectivity today's vacationers expect. The property's tropical setting centers around an inviting swimming pool with all-new equipment, generous lounging areas, and an open-air pavilion ideal for gathering with family and friends. Additional amenities include on-site laundry facilities and a separate outbuilding offering flexible storage or workshop space. Located on Sanibel's desirable East End, guests can enjoy convenient access to the island's celebrated shelling beaches, historic lighthouse, local restaurants, shopping, and miles of scenic bicycle paths. The peaceful surroundings and proximity to the Gulf create the quintessential Sanibel vacation experience. **THREE POTENTIAL HOMESITES. FOUR EXISTING RENTAL COTTAGES. ONE REMARKABLE ISLAND OPPORTUNITY.** Whether your vision is residential redevelopment or revitalizing a boutique vacation rental business, The Palms of Sanibel offers the location, flexibility, and existing improvements to bring that vision to life.

1220 Morningside PL, Sanibel

$890,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026044775 MLS

Tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac and surrounded by tropical plantings, 2042 Wild Lime Drive has that relaxed, private Sanibel feel that is getting harder to find. The home is open, bright and stylish, yet warm and comfortable, with abundant windows bringing the outdoors in and a large yard offering plenty of room to enjoy island life. The backyard directly abuts the J.N. Ding Darling National Wildlife Refuge, creating a peaceful natural backdrop filled with birds and island wildlife. Sit outside on the sunny patio, relax by the oversized heated saltwater pool, or simply enjoy the privacy of having protected refuge land as your rear neighbor. The location is equally special. Bowman’s Beach, known for its beautiful stretches of sand, incredible shelling and sunset views, is just a short bike ride away, with Blind Pass beaches also nearby. The Sanibel bike path is minutes from the house, making it easy to ride to the Sanibel Recreation Center, explore nearby nature trails or head out for a day on the island. Positioned toward the west end of Sanibel, you are conveniently located between the restaurants, shops and conveniences of Sanibel and everything Captiva has to offer. Inside, the home has undergone numerous improvements, including a beautifully remodeled kitchen with custom cabinetry, quartz countertops and upgraded appliances, hurricane-impact windows, updated HVAC and ductwork, luxury vinyl plank flooring, an updated primary bath and more. The oversized garage and lower-level bonus rooms provide an incredible amount of storage and flexible space for bikes, kayaks, paddleboards, fishing gear, hobbies and all the toys that come with island living. There is still an opportunity to make it your own. With a little imagination at the front entry and a few cosmetic touches, this home could be something truly special. This one surprised me. It has so much of what people come to Sanibel looking for; privacy, nature, a beautiful pool, room for all the island toys and the beach just a bike ride away. It feels tucked away in its own little neighborhood while still being perfectly positioned to enjoy both Sanibel and Captiva. Come see this one in person. I think you’ll understand why it feels special the minute you arrive.

2042 Wild Lime DR, Sanibel

$3,495,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026044706 MLS

Experience exceptional coastal living in this stunning 2024-built residence on Sanibel's desirable West Gulf Drive, just across the street from the beautiful Gulf beaches. Thoughtfully designed with sophisticated finishes and effortless indoor-outdoor living, this elevated 4-bedroom, 4-bath home offers the perfect blend of modern luxury and island charm. Step inside to discover a bright, open-concept interior featuring luxury vinyl plank flooring, elegant coastal finishes, and a striking shiplap accent wall with a sleek electric fireplace. The spectacular gourmet kitchen serves as the heart of the home, showcasing an expansive quartz-topped island with seating, custom white cabinetry, a decorative tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, a statement range hood, and stylish woven pendant lighting. A spacious dining area surrounded by windows creates an inviting setting for gatherings, while sliding glass doors open to a covered lanai overlooking the tropical surroundings. The generous primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with a spacious bedroom, walk-in closet, and beautifully appointed ensuite bath. Three additional bedrooms and bathrooms provide comfortable accommodations for family and guests. A private elevator offers convenient access between levels, while a dedicated laundry room and ample storage add everyday practicality. Step outside to your own private tropical oasis, where an expansive screened pool enclosure surrounds a sparkling swimming pool, generous paver deck, and multiple areas for lounging and entertaining. The covered outdoor living area provides a shaded retreat, while the impressive outdoor kitchen features a stainless steel grill, pizza oven, beverage refrigerator, and ample counter space, perfect for hosting poolside gatherings or enjoying casual island evenings. The ground level also offers generous garage parking and additional storage. Built in 2024 with impact-resistant windows and doors, this exceptional residence combines modern construction with timeless coastal appeal. Ideally located just steps from the beach, enjoy morning shelling, leisurely shoreline strolls, and the natural beauty that makes Sanibel Island so special. Whether you're seeking a luxurious full-time residence or an unforgettable island escape, this remarkable West Gulf Drive home delivers the ultimate Sanibel lifestyle!

4172 W Gulf DR, Sanibel

$949,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026044844 MLS

Ideally near the Sanibel Causeway, this turnkey island retreat offers convenient access on and off the island, with nearby beaches, boutique shopping, dining, golf and outdoor recreation. A bike path along Dixie Beach Boulevard invites leisurely rides through the island. Less than half a mile down Dixie Beach Boulevard, the scenic shores of San Carlos Bay are just a short visit or bike ride away, offering opportunities for shoreline fishing, wildlife watching and waterfront enjoyment. Surrounded by lush tropical gardens, mature palms and vibrant foliage, the property offers a serene, secluded atmosphere that captures the natural beauty and relaxed elegance of island living. This elevated three-bedroom, two-bath residence offers an inviting blend of timeless elegance, refined island living and thoughtful modern enhancements. The main living level features a light-filled, open-concept living and dining area, a beautifully appointed kitchen and a primary suite, creating a welcoming setting for everyday living and entertaining. The upper level offers a versatile retreat with a comfortable living area, a beautifully appointed guest bedroom, an additional bedroom serving as a home office with a step-out balcony and a charming bonus sleeping space with built-in bunk beds. Thoughtfully designed for flexibility, this inviting space is ideal for hosting family and friends while offering privacy and room to unwind. Significant improvements enhance comfort and peace of mind, including a 2018 roof, a new air-conditioning system in 2022, Hardie board siding and a water softener installed in 2023, a 2019 water heater and an updated interior electrical panel in 2026. Impact-resistant windows and doors provide additional storm protection, while smart-home features offer modern convenience. A spacious two-car garage with adjoining workshop and garden storage provides exceptional functionality. Beautifully landscaped outdoor spaces invite you to embrace Sanibel's year-round tropical climate, whether enjoying a quiet morning surrounded by nature or gathering with family and friends. The generous outdoor setting offers potential for a private pool or spa. This distinctive island residence presents an exceptional opportunity to enjoy the privacy, beauty and effortless lifestyle that make Sanibel so special.

1009 Dixie Beach BLVD, Sanibel

$599,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026044727 MLS

Don't miss your opportunity to own this charming 2-bedroom, 2-bath "Old Florida" cottage in the highly desirable Donax Village. Nestled on four lush tropical acres and just a short stroll to the beach, this beautifully updated home offers the perfect blend of island charm and modern convenience. Recent community improvements include the elevation of the villas, providing added peace of mind for owners. A welcoming front porch invites you into a bright, coastal-inspired interior featuring soothing island hues throughout. The updated kitchen boasts white cabinetry, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and plenty of space for everyday living or entertaining. Additional conveniences include an in-unit washer and dryer. Donax Village amenities include a sparkling community pool, tennis courts, and a grilling area, all surrounded by mature tropical landscaping. Additional grounds enhancements, including fresh seashell landscaping, are planned for completion soon, further complementing the community's charming island setting. Ideally located near shops, restaurants, and the Sanibel Causeway for easy on-and-off island access, this cottage is ready for you to embrace the laid-back Sanibel lifestyle. Live the island dream in this beautifully updated Donax Village retreat!

724 Donax ST Unit 10, Sanibel

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.

SI01 - Sanibel Island Homes with Yes Pets

Newest SI01 - Sanibel Island Homes with Yes Pets

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?